A Pharmacist’s Open Letter To Anyone Who Runs On Coffee:
Why More American Coffee Drinkers Are Switching To Energy Gummies Packed With Caffeine & L-Theanine
A closer look at the increasingly popular combination designed to support energy and focus while reducing the jitters and crash commonly associated with caffeine.
Dear coffee drinker,
My name is Maya Castellano, and I’ve been a licensed pharmacist for 12 years.
The question I hear most at my counter has nothing to do with a prescription. It’s this:
“Why does my coffee make me feel like this?”
Shaky hands by 10AM. A wall at 3PM so hard you’re bargaining for a second cup. Then 11PM, exhausted and wired at the same time.
Here’s what surprises almost everyone:
Your energy isn’t controlled by how much caffeine you take. It’s controlled by how it’s served.
In a moment, I’ll show you the ingredient nature has paired with caffeine for over 1,000 years, and why the way most people try it usually doesn’t work.
But first, you need to know what’s really happening at 3PM.
The 3PM crash isn’t what you think
Caffeine doesn’t actually give you energy.
All day, your brain builds up adenosine, its “time to rest” signal. Caffeine simply blocks that signal.1 But behind the block, the adenosine keeps piling up.
So when your cup wears off, the whole backlog lands at once. That’s the crash.
And it lingers. Caffeine’s average half-life is about five hours.1 A 200mg can at 2PM still leaves about 50mg in you at midnight. Half a cup of coffee, right as your head hits the pillow.
I explain it like this. The way most of us take caffeine is a light switch with one setting: blinding. Everything floods on at once, your hands shake, your heart races. Then it flips off, and the room goes dark.
What your body wants is a dimmer.
I call this the Naked Caffeine Spike. Caffeine arrives naked, without its natural partner. It arrives all at once: one can often carries 150mg to 300mg, and the same 16oz coffee from the same shop has measured anywhere from 259mg to 564mg.2 And it’s a dose you didn’t choose.
Common, but NOT normal
Most people accept the shakes and the crash as the price of admission. They’re common. They’re not normal. And they’re not your fault.
Watch for these signs:
- Your hands or heart race within an hour of your cup
- You need a second cup to feel what the first one used to do
- You hit a wall between 2PM and 4PM
- You feel “wired but tired” in the evening
- Your body is exhausted at night, but your mind won’t switch off
Even one of these means it’s time to change how you take caffeine. Here’s what’s missing.
Caffeine’s missing partner
For more than 1,000 years, Zen monks drank green tea through long nights of meditation. They needed to stay awake for hours and sit perfectly still. Coffee would have given them the shakes. Tea didn’t, and nobody knew why.
The answer came in 1949, when a Japanese chemist found an amino acid in the tea leaf nobody had seen before: theanine.
By then, the coffee and energy drink world had already been built without it. Coffee has none. Most energy drinks never added it.
Caffeine presses the gas. L-theanine keeps a steady hand on the wheel.
In a controlled study in Nutritional Neuroscience, people who took caffeine with L-theanine switched between tasks faster and more accurately, and were less thrown by distractions.3 A review of 11 controlled trials found the pair supported alertness and attention within two hours.4
Why not just drink green tea? A cup has only a tiny amount of L-theanine. You’d need about fifteen cups to match a studied amount.
The 3 things caffeine needs to work with you
Once you see these, you’ll be tempted to grab one of those “focus” energy drinks with L-theanine on the can.
STOP. That’s the mistake I see most. I’ll explain why in a second.
#1: The partner, in a real amount. L-theanine you can count in milligrams on the label, ideally at least as much as the caffeine.
#2: A dose you can dial. People handle caffeine very differently, so one fixed cup or can is wrong for most of us. You want small, exact steps.
#3: The pairing locked into every step. If you take less, the L-theanine has to come with it in the same proportion. Otherwise you’re back to caffeine naked.
That’s why the “focus” can fails. The L-theanine is often buried in a blend with no milligrams listed, so you can’t tell if it’s a real amount. The can is one fixed dose, often 150mg to 300mg of caffeine. And with no number for the partner, you never know the pairing, whether you sip half or crack a second one.
Decaf and mushroom coffee each miss at least one of the three too.
My #1 choice: Proper Wild Energy Gummies
When I first heard “energy gummies,” I rolled my eyes. Then I read the label, and realized someone had finally built caffeine with a dimmer.
Proper Wild calls it Pair & Dial.
The Pair. Every packet has 100mg of caffeine from green tea, about a cup of coffee, paired with 120mg of L-theanine. That’s about fifteen cups of green tea’s worth.
The Dial. The packet is four gummies, and each one holds 25mg of caffeine with its own 30mg of L-theanine. Take one, two or all four, and the partner always comes with it.
- 1 gummy: a gentle lift if you’re sensitive to caffeine
- 2 gummies: the 2PM reset most people need
- 4 gummies: a coffee’s worth for the long day
It takes effect in 15 to 30 minutes and lasts 4 to 6 hours.* No artificial sweeteners, no sugar alcohols, vegan. A full packet has 15g of sugar from organic cane, so two gummies is half that. And they taste like a strawberry fruit snack, which I’ve never said about a supplement.
Proper Wild is in more than 50,000 stores and has been tried by more than 1 million people. In an IRB-approved study of Proper Wild shots, made with the same active ingredients, 83% reported increased productivity.5
How I’d take it: start with one or two gummies 30 minutes before you usually fade. Adjust up over a few days until it feels right. Take your last one at least six hours before bed.
Don’t take my word for it
★★★★★
“I am super sensitive to caffeine, so I was leery to try these, but they are a game changer.”
Verified buyer
★★★★★
“I was very skeptical, but I no longer need to make coffee at 5 pm to keep me going. And I only take 2 gummies!”
Mary Jo S., verified buyer
★★★★★
“I have always had to fight through that 2 pm crash for most of my working life. They are the most effective solution I have ever tried…”
P. Thomas, verified buyer
Two boxes to find your dose
Right now, first-time subscribers get two 10-packs for the price of one: 20 packets for $39.99. That’s about $2 a packet, less than a grande coffee, with free shipping. It’s one packet for every workday afternoon for a month, and plenty to find your number.
- 2 × 10-pack boxes (80 gummies)
- Free shipping
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- Skip, pause or cancel anytime by text
After your first order, your subscription renews at 2 × 10-packs for $63.98 every month (about $3.20 a packet) until you skip, pause or cancel. We’ll email you 3 days before every delivery.
Try it for 30 days. If your afternoons aren’t steadier, Proper Wild will give you your money back.
You already know the old way doesn’t work. The only thing missing was the partner.
To your steadier afternoons,
Dr. Maya Castellano, PharmD
P.S. The short version: the jitters and the 3PM crash come from taking caffeine naked, all at once. Proper Wild locks L-theanine into every 25mg gummy so you can dial your energy without losing the pairing. Your first order is two boxes for the price of one. Claim yours here →
Sources
- StatPearls: Caffeine. NCBI, updated May 29, 2024.
- McCusker RR, Goldberger BA, Cone EJ. Journal of Analytical Toxicology, 2003.
- Owen GN, et al. Nutritional Neuroscience, 2008.
- Camfield DA, et al. Nutrition Reviews, 2014.
- Proper Wild IRB-approved 28-day study of Proper Wild Energy Shots (same active ingredients as the gummies).