Subscribe & Save with Free Shipping. 
TL;DR: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
Choose Proper Wild if you want organic green tea caffeine paired with 120mg L-theanine for focused, sustained energy, plus a clean label free of artificial sweeteners. Choose GummiShot if you prefer a higher caffeine dose per gummy (75mg per gummy vs Proper Wild's 25mg) and want fewer gummies per serving. For most people looking for a reliable coffee replacement that keeps them sharp for 4-6 hours without the crash, Proper Wild's formulation delivers more per serving.
Quick comparison table
| Feature | Proper Wild | GummiShot |
|---|---|---|
| Caffeine per gummy | 25mg (natural green tea) | 75mg (green coffee bean) |
| Caffeine per serving | 100mg (4 gummies) | 75-225mg (1-3 gummies per pouch) |
| L-theanine | 120mg per serving | None |
| Serving size | 4 gummies | 1-3 gummies (3 per pouch) |
| Caffeine source | Organic green tea extract | Green arabica coffee beans |
| Artificial sweeteners | None | Contains sucralose |
| Artificial flavors | None | Contains artificial flavors |
| Sugar per serving | 15g (from cane sugar and fruit juice) | 9g per pouch (3 gummies) |
| Flavors | Strawberry, Sour Lemon Lime | Tropical, Valencia Orange, Elderberry |
| Price per serving | $3.99 MSRP / as low as $2.40 with subscription | ~$2.50-$3.00 per pouch (varies by retailer) |
| Retail availability | 65,000+ stores including Walmart, Amazon | Amazon, gummishot.com |
| Vegan | Yes | Vegetarian (gelatin-free) |
| Made in USA | Yes | Yes |
What is Proper Wild?
Proper Wild makes clean energy gummies and shots built around a specific formula: 100mg of natural caffeine from green tea paired with 120mg of L-theanine per serving. That caffeine-to-L-theanine ratio is the core of the product. L-theanine is an amino acid found naturally in tea leaves that has been studied for its ability to promote calm focus when combined with caffeine; Proper Wild delivers 15x more L-theanine than a standard cup of green tea.
Each serving is four gummies. The ingredient list is short and readable: no artificial sweeteners, no artificial flavors, no stevia, no sucralose. Sweetness comes from cane sugar and natural fruit juice concentrates. The gummies are vegan, gluten-free, GMO-free, dairy-free, and soy-free.
Proper Wild sells direct through properwild.com with subscription discounts up to 40% off (bringing the per-serving cost from $3.99 down to $2.40). The brand is also stocked in over 65,000 retail locations including Walmart and Amazon, plus more than 400 airport stores. They also make energy shots in six flavors for people who prefer a liquid format.
The company positions itself around what it calls "Innocent Energy": energy that respects your body. The focus is on organic green tea caffeine (which has a longer half-life than synthetic caffeine, meaning a smoother uptake curve), L-theanine for focus support, and real ingredients over artificial fillers.
What is GummiShot?
GummiShot launched in 2021 as what the company calls the first energy shot in gummy form. Each gummy contains 75mg of caffeine derived from green arabica coffee beans, and each pouch holds three gummies for a total of 225mg of caffeine. The brand's main selling point is customizable dosing: take one gummy for a moderate boost, two for more energy, or all three for a dose comparable to an energy shot.
GummiShot comes in three flavors: Tropical (with pineapple and mango fruit powder), Valencia Orange (with orange powder), and Elderberry (with elderberry juice concentrate). The gummies are vegetarian, gelatin-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and free from artificial colors.
The brand sells primarily through Amazon and its own website (gummishot.com). GummiShot offers subscription options with 10% savings, and a free trial variety pack (you pay $6.95 shipping) that rolls into an 8-pouch subscription every two weeks. They also sell 15-count and 33-count bottles on Amazon for those who prefer bulk buying over individual pouches.
GummiShot's products are made in the United States in an NSF Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) certified, allergen-free facility.
Ingredients: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
This is where the two products diverge most.
Proper Wild's formulation centers on the caffeine-plus-L-theanine combination. The 100mg of organic green tea caffeine and 120mg of L-theanine per serving work together; research on this pairing suggests it may support both energy and focused attention while reducing the jittery edge that caffeine alone can produce. The rest of the ingredient list reads clean: organic fruit juice concentrates for flavor, cane sugar, pectin, and natural colors. No artificial sweeteners. No artificial flavors.
GummiShot delivers 75mg of caffeine per gummy from green coffee bean extract, but does not include L-theanine or other focus-supporting compounds. The ingredient panel includes cane sugar, organic tapioca syrup, and glycerin as the base, followed by citric acid, natural and artificial flavors, pea protein, pectin, sodium citrate, and sucralose.
Two points stand out in the ingredient comparison. First, L-theanine: Proper Wild includes it, GummiShot does not. For people who find that caffeine alone makes them feel wired or anxious, L-theanine can make a meaningful difference in energy quality. Second, artificial ingredients: GummiShot contains both artificial flavors and sucralose (an artificial sweetener), while Proper Wild uses neither. For consumers who read labels closely, and surveys show that number is growing every year, the cleaner label is a tangible advantage.
Winner: Proper Wild. The natural caffeine source, L-theanine pairing, and absence of artificial sweeteners and flavors give Proper Wild the edge for ingredient-conscious buyers.
Caffeine and energy quality: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
Proper Wild delivers 100mg of caffeine per serving from organic green tea extract. Green tea caffeine has a different absorption profile than coffee bean caffeine; its longer half-life contributes to a smoother energy curve. Combined with 120mg of L-theanine, Proper Wild is designed to deliver 4-6 hours of sustained energy and focus with a reduced crash and reduced jitters.
GummiShot provides 75mg per gummy, with the flexibility to scale up. One gummy is roughly equivalent to a cup of coffee; the full three-gummy pouch delivers 225mg, which puts it in the range of a standard energy shot. The brand sources its caffeine from green arabica coffee beans. Without L-theanine or other balancing ingredients, the energy profile is straightforward caffeine stimulation.
There is a meaningful difference in the dosing approach. Proper Wild's 25mg-per-gummy format makes it easy to microdose: one gummy for a light lift, two for a moderate boost, or the full four-gummy serving for 100mg. GummiShot's 75mg-per-gummy format is less flexible; even a single gummy delivers a substantial caffeine hit, with no easy way to take a smaller dose.
For people who want focused, balanced energy rather than a pure caffeine spike, the Proper Wild formula has a structural advantage. The L-theanine pairing is not a marketing add-on; the caffeine-plus-L-theanine combination is one of the most studied nootropic pairings in nutritional science.
Winner: Proper Wild for energy quality, sustained focus, and dosing flexibility.
Taste and texture: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
Proper Wild offers two gummy flavors: Strawberry and Sour Lemon Lime. The gummies use natural fruit juice for flavoring and have a pectin base. With over 1,600 reviews averaging 4.7 out of 5 stars, taste is a consistent bright spot. Customers frequently describe them as tasting like a treat rather than a supplement. Verified buyer Kainan P. wrote that the gummies taste good and that the energy kicks in fast. Another reviewer, Samuel, described both flavors as delicious, noting that the energy effect was noticeable within minutes.
GummiShot has three flavors: Tropical, Valencia Orange, and Elderberry. Each uses real fruit powder or juice concentrate for flavoring. Reviews on Amazon are mixed; while many customers find the taste pleasant, a common piece of feedback is that the taste could be better, with some noting a lingering aftertaste that may be related to the sucralose in the formula. Price-to-taste value is another recurring theme in GummiShot reviews.
Texture-wise, both products use a pectin base rather than gelatin, making them suitable for vegetarian and vegan diets (Proper Wild is fully vegan). Proper Wild's gummies are slightly larger since four make up a serving, while GummiShot's single gummies are smaller and more portable per unit.
Winner: Proper Wild, based on review volume and consistency of positive taste feedback.
Pricing: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
Proper Wild sells a 10-pack of gummies (24 servings total, 4 gummies per serving packet) for $39.99 at full retail. That works out to $3.99 per serving at MSRP. Subscribers get 20% off ($31.99 / 10-pack), bringing the per-serving cost to about $3.20. Subscribing to 5 or more items unlocks 40% off, dropping the price to $2.40 per serving.
GummiShot's pricing varies by format. Individual pouches (3 gummies each) come in multi-packs. An 8-pack on their website or a 10-pack on Amazon runs in the $20-$25 range depending on promotions, putting each pouch between $2.00 and $3.00. Their subscription offers 10% savings. Bulk bottles (15-count and 33-count) are available on Amazon.
At face value, GummiShot appears less expensive per pouch. But the comparison requires context. A single GummiShot pouch (225mg caffeine) delivers more than double the caffeine of a Proper Wild serving (100mg), so you are paying for a higher raw caffeine dose. However, Proper Wild includes 120mg of L-theanine, which GummiShot does not include at all. Buying L-theanine separately as a standalone supplement typically costs $0.15-$0.30 per 100mg dose.
When you factor in the L-theanine, the clean ingredient profile, and the subscription savings, Proper Wild's effective price gap narrows. At $2.40 per serving with the bulk subscription discount, Proper Wild costs less than a single coffee shop purchase and includes functional ingredients that GummiShot charges nothing for because it does not offer them.
Winner: GummiShot wins on sticker price. Proper Wild wins on value per ingredient dollar.
Availability: Proper Wild vs GummiShot
Proper Wild has a large retail footprint. The brand is stocked in over 65,000 retail locations across the United States, including Walmart and more than 400 airport stores. It is also available on Amazon, through the Proper Wild website, and via Instacart for same-day delivery in many areas.
GummiShot sells through Amazon and its own website (gummishot.com). The brand does not appear to have a brick-and-mortar retail presence. For consumers who prefer to grab energy products in stores or who like to try before committing to a subscription, this is a limiting factor.
Winner: Proper Wild, with significantly broader availability.
Choose Proper Wild if you:
- Want caffeine balanced with L-theanine for focused energy, not a wired feeling
- Care about clean ingredients and want to avoid artificial sweeteners and artificial flavors
- Prefer buying from a brand available in stores near you, not online-only
- Need 4-6 hours of sustained energy for work, parenting, workouts, or studying
- Are replacing coffee and want something gentler on your stomach
Choose GummiShot if you:
- Want the flexibility to take one small gummy at a time for a lighter caffeine dose
- Prefer a lower price point per unit and are less concerned about artificial ingredients
- Like variety in fruit flavors (three options vs two)
- Primarily shop on Amazon and prefer a direct-ship subscription model
Frequently asked questions
Does Proper Wild contain artificial sweeteners?
No. Proper Wild uses cane sugar and natural fruit juice concentrates for sweetness. There is no sucralose, stevia, aspartame, or other artificial sweeteners in the formula.
Does GummiShot contain artificial sweeteners?
Yes. GummiShot's ingredient list includes sucralose, which is an artificial sweetener. It also contains artificial flavors.
How much caffeine is in Proper Wild vs GummiShot?
Proper Wild contains 100mg of natural caffeine from green tea per serving (4 gummies). GummiShot contains 75mg of caffeine from green coffee beans per gummy, with 225mg total per 3-gummy pouch.
Does GummiShot have L-theanine?
No. GummiShot does not include L-theanine. Proper Wild includes 120mg of L-theanine per serving, which is 15x the amount found in a cup of green tea.
Where can I buy Proper Wild?
Proper Wild is available at properwild.com, Amazon, Walmart, and over 65,000 retail locations including 400+ airport stores. Subscriptions on properwild.com offer up to 40% off.
Is GummiShot available in stores?
GummiShot is primarily sold online through Amazon and gummishot.com. It does not appear to have widespread brick-and-mortar retail distribution.
Are Proper Wild gummies vegan?
Yes. Proper Wild gummies are 100% vegan, gluten-free, GMO-free, dairy-free, stevia-free, and soy-free.
Are GummiShot gummies vegan?
GummiShot describes its gummies as vegetarian-friendly. They are gelatin-free and use a pectin base.
The verdict
Both Proper Wild and GummiShot deliver caffeine in a convenient gummy format, and both are better options than sugary energy drinks for people who want portable energy. The difference comes down to what you value.
Proper Wild's 100mg organic green tea caffeine plus 120mg L-theanine formula is purpose-built for clean, focused energy. The ingredient list is free of artificial sweeteners and flavors. It is stocked in over 65,000 stores, backed by over 1,600 reviews at a 4.7-star average, and offers deep subscription discounts that bring the per-serving price to $2.40.
GummiShot offers a lower entry price, but without L-theanine, with artificial ingredients in the formula, and with limited availability outside of Amazon.
For people serious about what goes into their body and how their energy feels (not just whether they get a caffeine hit), Proper Wild is the stronger choice.